Whether you have carpet or hardwood floors in your home, shoes can drag in water and dirt that can leave unsightly stains that won’t come out. Not to mention, their soles can bring in bacteria that causes infection, too. Using a doormat for your shoes or a boot tray is a great way to stay organized and keep your home’s surfaces protected. To help narrow down your search, we rounded up our favorite options. Each pick we included in our selection is sturdy, waterproof and able to hold at least three pairs of shoes.
For more than 75 years, Footwear News has been the shoe authority. Our coverage spans top industry news, retail trends, head-to-toe fashion, athletic and outdoor analysis and more. Footwear News’ global network of editors has carefully curated all product selections featured using our expansive brand knowledge and thorough research to find quality, long-lasting items. If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission.
1. Gorilla Grip Heavy Duty Doormat
Available in five sizes, this mat features a grippy rubber base with an attractive woven polypropylene fabric on top.
Pros: It’s vacuum-friendly, absorbs grime and moisture, and can fit in most spaces. It’s available in a range of patterned options and colors.
Cons: It might have a temporary rubber smell.
2. Slip To Grip Universal Doormat
Made from BPA-free fiber, this styles comes in three neutral colors with a weatherproof soft rubber surface to withstand the elements.
Pros: The top layer is also non-slippery to keep feet stable. The item is washer-dryer friendly for easy maintenance.
Cons: A heavy item might be needed initially to keep it flat.
3. Mibao Shoe Tray
Made from recycled plastic, this mat features raised edges to contain any water, dirt or debris from all kinds of shoes.
Pros: It comes in a two-pack and is resistant to many solvents. It can hold up to three pairs of shoes and makes a great option for holding dog bowls, too.
Cons: Some users may prefer it was more flexible.
4. Stalwart Shoe Mat
This product also features 100% recycled polypropylene construction that can stand up to frequent water and dirt exposure.
Pros: A 1.25-inch raised lip prevents messes from occurring. It comes in small, medium and large sizes to store multiple pairs of shoes.
Cons: The sticker should be removed.
5. BirdRock Home Shoe Mat
This option is made of durable, flexible rubber that won’t become brittle in cold temperatures.
Pros: It can hold four to five pairs of shoes and features an ornate design inside. It also includes 2-inch tall ledges to prevent water from spilling over.
Cons: The product is under 8 pounds.
6. Amagabeli Garden & Home Doormat
This mat includes a washable surface and 100% rubber backing that won’t slip around with use.
Pros: It’s quick-drying is easy to vacuum to minimize cleanup time. It’s also available in two sizes and five colors for more buying options.
Cons: There might be a rubber smell.