9 Greatest Super Bowl Moments & The Shoes That Made Them Happen

SUPER BOWL XLII
David Tyree's "helmet catch" during Super Bowl XLII is considered one of the game's greatest catches in its 50-year history.
AP Images.

As the 50th anniversary of the Super Bowl approaches this weekend, Footwear News is rewinding the clock to look back at some key moments in the game’s history.

Earlier this week, we reviewed some of the best footwear ads to air during the commercial break. Now we turn our attention to the real focus: the miraculous on-the-field moments that earned a place in our collective minds and hearts.

Here, we offer our favorites in a highly subjective (and probably controversial) ranking, and also reveal the footwear brands that led these athletes to victory — or in some cases defeat.

1. SUPER BOWL XLII

Year: 2008
The Teams: New York Giants vs. New England Patriots
The Big Play: After shaking off a fierce defensive attack, Giants quarterback Eli Manning fired one down field to wide receiver David Tyree, who miraculously caught the ball on top of his helmet.
On His Feet: Manning was in Reebok and Tyree was wearing Nike

2. SUPER BOWL XLIII

Year: 2009
Teams: Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Arizona Cardinals
The Big Play: Steeler James Harrison intercepted a pass from Kurt Warner and returned it for a then-record 100-yard touchdown — a remarkable feat for anyone, but especially for a linebacker.
On His Feet: Harrison was wearing Nike

SUPER BOWL XLIII James Harrison races 100 yards to the end zone after intercepting a pass during Super Bowl XLIII. AP Images.

3. SUPER BOWL XXXIV

Year: 2000
Teams: St. Louis Rams vs. Tennessee Titans
The Big Play: During the final play of the game, Rams linebacker Mike Jones tackled Titans wide receiver Kevin Dyson one yard short of the goal line to prevent a potential game-tying touchdown.
On His Feet: Jones was wearing Nike

SUPER BOWL XXXIV Titans wide receiver Kevin Dyson tries and fails to reach the end zone in Super Bowl XXXIV. AP Images

4. SUPER BOWL XXV 

Year: 1991
Teams: Buffalo Bills vs. New York Giants
The Big Play: In a last-ditch effort, Bills placekicker Scott Norwood attempted a 47-yard field goal that missed the uprights, earning the game its nickname — Wide Right — and securing a win for the Giants.
On His Feet: Norwood was wearing Adidas

SUPER BOWL XXV Bills placekicker Scott Norwood hangs his head after missing his fateful field goal in Super Bowl XXV. AP Images.

5. SUPER BOWL XVIII

Year: 1984
Teams: Washington Redskins vs. L.A. Raiders
The Big Play: After a hand-off from quarterback Jim Plunkett, Raiders running back Marcus Allen showed off epic foot work, zigging and zagging across the field before eventually threading his way through a sea of defenders to complete a then-record 74-yard touchdown run.
On His Feet: Allen was in Puma

SUPER BOWL XVIII Marcus Allen 74-yard touchdown run during Super Bowl XVIII has become the stuff of legends. AP Images.

6. SUPER BOWL XLIX

Year: 2015
Teams: New England Patriots vs. Seattle Seahawks
The Big Play: With 26 seconds on the clock, rookie Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler shut down the Seahawks’ Super Bowl hopes when he intercepted a touchdown pass intended for Russell Wilson.
On His Feet: Butler was wearing Nike

SUPER BOWL XLIX Malcolm Butler intercepts a touchdown pass for Russell Wilson in Super Bowl XLIX. AP Images.

7. SUPER BOWL III 

Year: 1969
Teams: New York Jets vs. Baltimore Colts
The Big Play: In today’s game, bragging is nothing new, but quarterback Joe Namath shocked football fans when he guaranteed to a heckler in Miami that the Jets would defeat the Colts. Luckily, his team made good on the promise.
On His Feet: Namath was wearing Riddell

SUPER BOWL III Before the start of Super Bowl III, Joe Namath guaranteed a win for the New York Jets. AP Images.

8. SUPER BOWL X

Year: 1976
Teams: Dallas Cowboys vs. Pittsburgh Steelers
The Big Play: Steelers wide receiver Lynn Swann was named the MVP for his many heroics in the game, but his biggest moment was a 53-yard reception from quarterback Terry Bradshaw that bounced out of the hands of a Cowboy defender.
On His Feet: Swann was wearing Spalding

SUPER BOWL X Lynn Swann fights off a Cowboy defender to take down a pass from Terry Bradshaw in Super Bowl X. AP Images.

9. SUPER BOWL XXIII 

Year: 1989
Teams: Cincinnati Bengals vs. San Francisco 49ers
The Big Play: Following a 92-yard drive down the field in less than three minutes, 49ers quarterback Joe Montana found receiver John Taylor in the end zone for a game-winning 10-yard touchdown pass.
On His Feet: Montana was in Mizuno and Taylor was in Puma

SUPER BOWL XXIII Joe Montana celebrates with John Taylor after a game-winning touchdown in Super Bowl XXIII. AP Images.

Want More?

Greatest Super Bowl Shoe Commercials

Nike Celebrates Super Bowl 50 With Two New Collections

Bay Area Shoe Retailers Hoping For Super Bowl Traffic Spike

Remember This? Kim Kardashian Starred In A 2011 Skechers Super Bowl Ad